Comments

Criticism That Cuts — 4 Comments

  1. OUCH!!!
    A mentor would never say something so cutting, or at least a true mentor. I have a friend who was assigned a writing 'mentor' as well who did nothing constructive with her and it was devastating to hear her tell her tale.

    I agree, think before you criticize, and if you do have something to say, make it constructive and be sure to point out at least two positive details to each negative.

    I'm pleased this artist finally made found his way despite that beastly mentor.

  2. I'm sorry for your friend, Tess! Your suggestion to make two good points for every criticism is excellent. I hope mentors everywhere take it to heart! Thanks for reading and commenting, dear.

  3. I agree with you that folks need to be careful with their criticisms. Too often, people think that any criticism will "help improve," which is just silly. 🙂

  4. Agreed! Your own approach inspires instead of striking down, for which I'm grateful, A. Catherine. Thanks for commenting and for being you.